Great place. The flight is really good but you can't drink it all by yourself. Bring friends. Juevos Rancheros is not what you'd expect so beware. But the burritos chorizo style taste great! The blueberry tart is sour and sweet. And its nice calm spot.

Wow first time here and I love this place. Natalie was so amazing and kind. She made great conversation and was very attentive. The iced coffees are even tastier than they look. BONUS: the food is cooked to order. everything is fresh. Chicken is cooked to order. The kitchen is very clean. 10/10

Absolutely loved New City Coffee! Their coffee flight is a must-try—whether you prefer hot or iced, it’s the perfect way to taste a variety of their incredible brews. The pastries are out of this world, fresh and full of flavor. Make sure to check out the restaurant next door for an awesome charcuterie board—it’s the perfect pairing! And if Drew takes your order, you’re guaranteed a five-star experience. His attention to detail and friendly service make your visit even better. Conveniently located right across the street from Honor Church in Lake Mary, it’s the ideal spot to grab your coffee before heading to church on Sunday. A visit to New City Coffee and Honor Church makes for the perfect start to your week! Highly recommend!

I'm not a big coffee person so this review is based on my blueberry scone. This was the most delicious scone I've eaten in my entire life! The edges and peaks were crispy. The sugar in top was the perfect amount. Not too sugary. The inside was so delicately fresh. I wanted to go back and get another immediately. Next time you're there I highly recommend this.

Great little coffee spot to try a variety of coffee options with its own coffee flight! I ordered a cold flight with oat-milk. You get four little cups with all very different flavors. Although the Black Forest one its meant for hot coffee since it just sunk in the cup adding little to no flavor, the other three are tasty and not too sweet that overpowered the coffee flavor. Croissants were good although no option of getting them warm was suggested. Overall great experience and great coffee for all.

I've stopped in a few times now for the season options and I'm never disappointed. The flights are adorable and delicious and the bakery items are always great. I usually like iced coffees and they do a great job on the flavor combos within the coffee. I tried the Black Forest from the spring options and it was well balanced and really flavorful

So far I’ve had a good experience here. I heard about this place on Instagram/tiktok so I fully expected it to be busy and take forever. The first time I went it was just that, line out the door, 30 min wait, 30 min to get the coffee. To be fair there was also a farmers market happening across the street. Overall, the coffee was really really good. I got the iced seasonal coffee flight for October, all of them not too sweet, not too bitter. The second time I went, I got just a regular sized seasonal iced coffee and it was, again perfectly made. Not too sweet, not too bitter so I ordered a 2nd one because the large is a little small for me. The third time I went I got another seasonal coffee flight this time in spring and it was also incredibly delicious. I have to say, they just make good coffee. Plus we also tried the breakfast sandwich, and it was also incredible, doesn’t taste processed like most places.

Cute atmosphere! Great location and employee was so friendly!!! My teddy bear Lavender Honey Latte was delicious